Sunday, December 2, 2012

Finding a "Qualified Yoga Teacher" - 3 Things Students Need to Know

by: Victoria McColm, Founder & Editor - Prevent Yoga Injury

If you've done any research on your yoga contraindication, or on yoga safety in general, then you've been advised to practice only with a "qualified yoga teacher." But what does that mean exactly? How do you evaluate your teacher based on your specific needs? And what the heck do all those different letters behind his or her name mean? Read on to understand a little about the kinds of yoga teachers that are out there, how they're certified, what they learn and how to make sure you're working with someone who fits and understands your specific needs.


1) The Yoga Industry Self Regulates 

The first thing that's important for the context of evaluation, is to understand that state governments do not regulate or license yoga teachers or studios in the United States. There are passionate advocates and arguments on both sides of the licensing/regulation debate that I'll save for a future post. Regardless of whether it's a good or a bad idea, what it means for you is that you don't have the same kind of consumer protection or peace of mind that you might with your masseuse, personal trainer, therapist or even your hair stylist - all of which must be licensed and meet credentialing requirements in most states prior to offering services to the public. 

You have to take responsibility for your own yoga safety, and to do that, you need to understand the industry landscape and where to go for information. There are two main standards and self-regulating bodies within the yoga industry: Yoga Alliance & the International Association of Yoga Therapists. Most teachers today have trained with schools that are certified by one or the other or both. 

2) Credentialing is Done via Honor System

Yoga Alliance certifies schools and teachers who have earned a certificate of completion from one of the schools they certify. They have been in business since 1999 and recently went through a soul search and leadership change aimed at professionalizing their own organization and deciding what they should actually be providing to teachers and the industry based on inputs from yoga teachers nationwide. They confer two main designations, along with additional designations for experience and specialties. Here's what they actually mean:

  • RYS = Registered Yoga School: To become a RYS, a program applies to Yoga Alliance outlining the intended curriculum and showing it meets the minimum standards established for teacher training. Besides curriculum, the only hard requirement is that the primary teacher(s) be experienced registered yoga teachers (E-RYT) with Yoga Alliance. Check out the RYS application. YA is a small operation and there is no physical visit to the training program applicant by YA staff to verify the information submitted. Changes to curriculum are accomplished via a self-reporting honor system.  Training quality and content can vary widely among schools.
  • RYT200 = Registered Yoga Teacher with at least 200hrs of training. Minimum curriculum standards.
  • E-RYT200 = Experienced Registered Yoga Teacher with at least 200hrs of training + 1,000hrs of teaching experience. Minimum standards are same as above, these teachers have just been in business longer.
  • RYT500 = Registered Yoga Teacher with at least 500hrs of training. Minimum curriculum/experience standards
  • E-RYT500 = Experienced Registered Yoga Teacher with at least 500hrs of training + at least 1,000hrs of teaching experience
  • RCYT = Registered Children's Yoga Teacher has 200hr RYT certification + 95hrs of specialized training in children's yoga. RCYT minimum standards link
  • RPYT = Registered PreNatal Yoga Teacher has 200hr RYT certification + 85hrs of specialized training in prenatal yoga. RPYT minimum standards link
Yoga Alliance allows its members to list their credentials publicly on their website. A final plus is that each of their designations requires various hours of continuing education to maintain over time. So, a listing on YA means that your teacher has completed some formal training and is dedicated to continuing education and improving or expanding their yoga skill set. It's definitely worth having a look to make sure your teacher is listed, just don't base your decision on a YA listing alone.

The other major standards organization is called the International Association of Yoga Therapists (IAYT). Its was formed in 1989, rolled into another organization in 1999, and then became independent again in 2004. The organization has reportedly experienced controversy in its history(1), but its reputation is improving as its leadership seek to further professionalize and develop credentialing standards for yoga therapists. 

Yoga therapy is the practice of applying yoga techniques (postures, breathing, diet, etc) to treat or relieve a specific ailment or medical condition. The field of yoga therapy is still somewhat of a free for all. There are lots of teachers out there who interpret their Yoga Alliance bestowed "RYT" designation as teacher or therapist, interchangeably. In fact, there is no such thing as a "Registered Yoga Therapist", so a healthy bit of skepticism should be employed when evaluating any teacher who claims to be one. There are many well known and respected yoga therapists practicing today, many of whom have medical degrees in addition to their yoga training. If you're unsure whether the yoga therapist you've found is really qualified, a suggested best practice for students who want to use yoga for treatment is to seek out a yoga therapist who is also an MD (medical doctor), PT (physical therapist), RN (registered nurse) or other medical professional. All such individuals would have completed medical training at an accredited university and hold some sort of license to practice in the medical field, in addition to their yoga therapy training. 

There are efforts to professionalize yoga therapy training with minimum standards, that at some point, may manifest into a standardized credentialing system. This summer, the IAYT released The Educational Standards for the Training of Yoga Therapists. I've read it, and I think it's a fantastic step forward. They call for teachers who want to designate as yoga therapists to undertake a minimum of 800hrs of training over a minimum of two years, on top of a 200hr RYT and one year of experience prerequisite.


3) Evaluating a Teacher with Your Instincts

So, what's the best way to evaluate a teacher, who reported her credentials via honor system to an organization that doesn't yet have the capacity or resources  to verify teacher training quality first hand, in an industry that self regulates? That question is not meant to be a poke at anyone, it's simply the state of affairs in the yoga industry, like it or not. At the end of the day, you just have to trust your gut. If you experience any of the situations below on a regular basis, it's a good idea to consider looking for a new guru.

   Serious Ego - One of the main things you're supposed to be learning in yoga is how to let go of self and ego and connect with source. Be wary of anyone who self-designates as a guru, chastises your lifestyle choices or motives for pursuing yoga, is unavailable or unwilling to make time for you before or after class or is generally unfriendly or unapproachable. If your teacher displays serious ego, then he or she clearly has a lot more to learn and might not be the best person guide your journey. 

   Seriously Flakey - If your teacher's mantra is "everything is perfect" when it's clearly not, you may have a problem. Is he often late? Is the studio dirty? Does he want you to describe your very personal and potentially embarrassing contraindication in front of the entire class? Does he not ask about injuries or contraindications at all? Letting go of self does not mean letting go of consideration for others and it leaves you wondering what other corners are being cut (intentionally or not).

   Seriously Spiritual, like, seriously - Spirituality without substance is another red flag. Often a quote, anecdote or spiritual reference can be the perfect thing to take your mind off that grocery list and into your practice. But if every question you ask your teacher is seemingly dodged with some vapid spiritual reference, then be careful. Masking inexperience or lack of knowledge with a veil of spiritual superiority is unfortunately common in the industry. A good teacher knows what she doesn’t know and is not afraid to make that admission or connect you with a teacher who can help. 

Many students come to yoga because they are seeking or want to fix something, and that attitude can put a student in a vulnerable position in which the inherent authority of the teacher might cause second guessing of his or her own instincts. There are amazing yoga teachers out there, mediocre ones and probably a few bad apples - just like in every other profession and practice. 

The biggest thing I hope you’ll take away from this article is that there are no rules in yoga – and that is both a good and bad thing. The most important way to evaluate the quality of your teacher is by educating yourself on yoga basics, knowing yourself, what you want or expect out of your practice and listening to your body. Find a teacher who makes you feel comfortable. 

Are there other ways to ensure you're working with a "qualified yoga teacher"? Please share them in the comments section!

UPDATE (17 DEC 2012): (1) Source: William J. Broad, "The Science of Yoga"

7 comments:

  1. I really like your article.it is about time to explain to the students of yoga to be aware of whom they take classes with
    Also to educate about philosophy
    learning limbs and sutras
    Really any person who has the luck to feel the Magic of the practice should take training
    to understand better what they are doing with their bodies and learn how to protect themselves
    Seriously stay away from corporations.choose a good teacher that teaches good alignment.movement without alignment is just jokes without grace.ultimately you will learn that one of the stronger lessons you can learn from this practice is to felt in love with discipline
    Namaste
    Marta Berry
    Malasanayoga.com





    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Marta! That's great advice for students too!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you for your work raising awareness around yoga safety Victoria. Educating the consumers and teachers of yoga regarding safety is an ongoing process and you nicely outlined important points for readers.

    In your bio I believe I read your interest in sustaining dialog vs knee jerk/visceral responses you witnessed to the Broad book etc? I'd be curious to better understand your statement about IAYT "The organization has experienced controversy in its history, but its reputation is improving." I have more than a little familiarity with the organization (www.drofyoga.com) and am only aware of some misstatements by Broad in his book. Would you be willing to share with the readers what those controversies were, with whom you've checked the facts around the controversy beyond his statements in the book, and how those have been resolved? I believe it's important to discern the facts at this point to either forewarn or reassure the public regarding the groups working for public safety/ahimsa.

    Finally, your readers may enjoy this article I wrote on the topic in the PubMed accepted journal of the yoga therapy by IAYT (meaning the articles are peer reviewed and accepted as evidence by the gold standard in this country...ie, reputable). http://matthewjtaylor.com/consciousahimsa.pdf I also presented on this topic of safety at the first ever Symposium of Yoga Therapy and Research (SYTAR) in 2007. Teachers and consumers will find additional action steps in the article toward ahimsa in their practice. The standards you highlighted form the content for our upcoming Symposium (www.sytar.org) in Boston 2013 that features the world's top authorities presenting on how those standards can be engaged. I mention all this because again Broad made numerous factual misstatements and my review of the facts on the public record of dialog demonstrates there is no other group or organization that has taken "right action" toward the yama of ahimsa on the level IAYT has in the past 8 years since its reorganization (research, education, standards development, and membership prof development).
    Continued success in your important mission Victoria and let me know if I can be of further support or collaborate at some level. Namaste, Matt

    ReplyDelete
    Replies

    1. Matt -

      Thank you so much for your comments and my apologies for the delay in responding. I will do my best to respond to the issues you raise below.

      First, I want to stress that I do not consider myself, nor am I attempting to portray myself as, an "expert.” You mentioned my bio; I have now updated it to reflect any potential misunderstandings regarding my intentions for this work. I am merely a facilitator, working to gather information on yoga safety, best practice and contraindications in a single place and convey it in a manner that is easily understood by the average practitioner - something that is currently missing in yoga discourse and available resources. I do hold a Master's degree in Philosophy and Policy from the London School of Economics, have practiced yoga for about eight years now and received my RYT200 in June 2012, in case you are curious.

      I acknowledge your statements regarding IAYT. This article is not meant to be a thesis on yoga safety, it merely pulls together publicly available information at a high level to ensure yoga students understand the need to be cognizant of their own safety when choosing a teacher. I regard the published opinion of a respected journalist a credible source for an article written at this level and ensured balance in my statements regarding IAYT. I am actually quite positive about the organization (and personally excited about the direction they are moving) in my writing. To answer your question, I did not speak to anyone directly to verify Broad's opinion for this article, because it is not an expose. But I thank you for raising this issue in the comments section. I have updated the article to reflect my source for that statement, in case others are wondering about its origin. What's most important is that students have access to all points of view so that they can make up their own minds on these issues. Just as you wish for readers to hear your facts, Broad stands by his. It is not my place to bestow authority to one or the other, but present both in order for readers to decide for themselves. If you would like to go deeper into the inaccuracies that you see in his work, I would welcome it here. Again, it's important for readers to hear both sides.

      Thank you so much for sharing your "Conscious Ahimsa" article. I would love to find a way to resurrect this concept for the PYI blog. If you would be interested in writing an article, I would welcome it.

      Finally, regarding the symposiums you mentioned, I would like to offer the following: these types of events are critical for moving thinking on the practice forward, but you must agree with me that they are inaccessible to most. How much does it cost to attend? The average practitioner will never know what transpired at SYTAR this year, and likely couldn't afford to attend even if he wanted to. Please don't take this as me trivializing the work that you are all doing, I believe it to be critical to the field. Rather, I want to highlight the need for both of our efforts. I would love to find ways to work together to disseminate the outcomes of such events and translate them into tangible best practices that your average yoga teacher, practitioner or doctor can understand.

      Thank you again for your comments – again my intent is to spark dialogue, so thank you for contributing to that. Please don’t hesitate to reach out.
      My best,
      Vic

      PS: In visiting the SYTAR website, there are lots of errors: The forums are down, FB and Twitter buttons are not set up correctly and the FAQ page is malfunctioning. Just wanted to let you know in case you know the webmaster, perhaps you can pass along...

      Delete
  4. Hello, thank you for the article...One of my personal concerns with how Yoga is portrayed and delivered now is that many, many teachers skip over the other 7 limbs. Asana is the main focus and I really hope more teachers will educate students that Yoga is a system... a path... a way of life... To practice Asana only without incorporating awareness of the other limbs is misguided and misguiding... Thank you again! Namaste, Lynn Louise Wonders, LPC, RPT-S, E-RYT200 www.wonderscounseling.com

    ReplyDelete
  5. Victoria, this seems like a terrific, in-depth, common sense overview of the issues involved in choosing a yoga teacher. You really embrace the consumer protection mantle far better than most people. In the interest of promoting the industry, their brand, or their favorite studio, some people only raise a few of these issues simply as caveats -- if at all.

    Off the top of my head, the only thing I might add is: the studio environment and the way the teacher handles issues like overcrowding, different yoga levels in the same class, permission to touch, and whether they use up valuable class time to aggressive marketing the studio, its workshops, retreats, and other classes. Not every teacher teaches in a studio, but studios, for marketing and financial reasons, do tend to push certain class practices. If the teacher trained and received her certification there, she will tend to be unduly "loyal" -- and that could be a factor.

    I'm not saying add a section, "Aggressively selling" or "Seriously sales-oriented" but just noting the issue as a factor that can affect the quality and safety of the yoga experience -- in my view.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Good article but I have a question. I am an ERYT that has decided to stop my current progress in a standard 500 hour training so that I can pursue a 500 hour (800 actually) therapeutic yoga training. The therapeutic training is IAYT approved and meets/exceeds their standards. I do not have a medical degree which is why I chose to change course. The IAYT standards are anatomy-heavy, which I like. So are you suggesting that students should avoid teachers like myself, with no medical background?

    Stacy

    ReplyDelete